Local Chiropractors Discuss: Surgery or Chiropractic for Chronic Sciatica Sufferers?

Dec. 12, 2013

Surgery or Chiropractic for Chronic Sciatica Sufferers?

Pain coming from compression or irritation of the sciatic nerve is called sciatica. Sciatica – which can include pain, tingling, numbness and muscle weakness – is really a symptom indicating an underlying problem, not a diagnosis in and of itself. This article will explore in detail the findings of a recent controlled study comparing spinal manipulation (chiropractic) and surgery for people whose sciatica did not respond to traditional medical treatment approaches.

The study discussed here was conducted by the National Spine Center in Alberta Canada and published in October of 2010 in the Journal of Manipulative and Physiological Therapeutics . The 40 study participants all had sciatica lasting over 3 months which had not responded to treatment with pain medications, lifestyle modifications, physical therapy, massage therapy or acupuncture. They had all been referred by their primary care physicians to spinal surgeons who had deemed them appropriate surgery candidates.

Instead of having all the patient proceed with surgery, they were split into two groups – one group to undergo a surgical microdiscectomy and the other group to be treated with standardized chiropractic spinal manipulation by a single chiropractor. (If not satisfied with the results they obtained from their assigned method, the patients were allowed to switch to the other treatment plan after 3 months.)

So what happened? Both groups made significant improvements over baseline scores – meaning that they saw noticeable improvements whereas previous approaches had failed. A full 60% of the study participants benefitted from chiropractic spinal manipulation to the SAME degree as if they underwent surgery. And, after 1 year there was no difference in outcome success based on the treatment method. That means that a full 60% of people referred for surgery by their primary care physicians and accepted as surgical candidates by the neurosurgeon could actually get similar results with chiropractic. That is a lot of potentially unnecessary cutting, anesthesia and ER time.

There is one paragraph in the results section of this study that is easy to overlook, but incredibly important. There were originally 120 candidates of which 60 met the study criteria and were asked to participate. Of these 60, 20 refused. Why? Because they had never been offered spinal manipulation as an alternative to surgery! They didn’t want to participate in the study and be randomly placed in the surgery group without first trying the spinal manipulation! This is incredibly telling. Not only does it demonstrate that there is still a lot of education about chiropractic that needs to happen among the public and among primary care providers, it also demonstrates that people understand the risks and costs of surgery and want to exhaust other possibilities first.

This was the first study to ever look at people who had failed traditional medical management of sciatica. Currently most patients that fail ‘conservative care’ are referred for a surgical evaluation. Now we know that 60% of these folks could avoid surgery and get similar long-term outcomes with chiropractic.

Please share this article with anyone considering surgery for sciatica.

For more information contact:
Dr’s Brad and Mandy Pearce
Pewaukee Family Chiropractic
1001 Cecelia Drive Pewaukee, WI 53072
Phone: 262-695-9206
Email: pewaukeefamilychiropractic@hotmail.com

This site uses Facebook comments to make it easier for you to contribute. If you see a comment you would like to flag for spam or abuse, click the "x" in the upper right of it. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use.

Suburban News Roundup

E-mail Newsletter

Your link to the biggest stories in the suburbs delivered Thursday mornings.

Enter your e-mail address above and click "Sign Up Now!" to begin receiving your e-mail newsletter
Get the Newsletter!

Login or Register to manage all your newsletter preferences.

Community Watch

» Woman drives car into Fox River in Waukesha 11/27

» Waukesha Police Report: Dec. 3, 2015 issue 11/27

» Later paper delivery for Waukesha Now's Nov. 26, 2015 issue 11/25

» Despite Meijer's request for a change, Waukesha stores must continue to sell liquor in separate area 11/25

» Reports of people dressed as clowns raise concerns in Waukesha Updated:  11/24

» Downtown Waukesha glows under LED snowflakes Updated:  11/24

» Waukesha Police Report: Nov. 26, 2015 issue 11/23

» New rule trickles into Waukesha's water conservation efforts 11/23

» Early deficit, long Homestead drive ends Waukesha West's title hopes 11/21

» 2015 Waukesha Christmas Parade, tree lighting kicks off holiday festivities 11/20

» Mistakes haunt Catholic Memorial in heartbreaking title-game loss 11/20

» Man found guilty of igniting standoff with police to enter treatment for mental illness Updated:  11/20

» Updated state championship game rankings of area prep football teams and players 11/19

» Waukesha Police Report: Nov. 19, 2015 issue Updated:  11/19

» Local NFL Punt, Pass & Kick national champion will be grand marshal in Waukesha Christmas Parade 11/19

» Judge: prison for woman who stole $21,000 from bank customers, climbed through ceiling for drugs Updated:  11/19

» Complaint: Teenager pointed gun at woman inside Waukesha apartment 11/18

» Woman reportedly cracked glass bowl over daughter's head during argument in Waukesha Updated:  11/17

» Waukesha man accused of collecting, sharing child porn for 13 years Updated:  11/17

» Complaint: Waukesha woman, with her kids with her car, crashed while intoxicated 11/16

» Catholic Memorial cruises into state final with all-around effort 11/15

» Waukesha West football rampages to state with 'unfinished business' in mind 11/14

» Citing 'low ethical standards,' Steve Edlund won't seek re-election on Waukesha School Board 11/13

» Waukesha Police Report: Nov. 12, 2015 issue 11/12

» Chairman Marek looks to build 42-unit housing development in town of Waukesha 11/11

View All Posts Got a tip? Welcome rss



Local Business Directory



What's Happening NOW

WaukeshaNOW.com and the Waukesha & Pewaukee Visitors Bureau are teaming up to provide you with an online calendar of community events and attractions. E-mail us to learn how to submit an event.